Discussion:
Could the Dominion Survive a Borg Invasion? | Star Trek (Dominion Vs The Borg)
Add Reply
Ubiquitous
2025-03-11 15:38:28 UTC
Reply
Permalink
In this video, We will be finding out could the Dominion survive a Borg
Invasion. We will be looking out their technology, ships, and military might.
We will also review the reason why the Borg only attack in small forces.



--
Not a joke! Don't jump!
john
2025-03-11 19:22:28 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Ubiquitous
In this video, We will be finding out could the Dominion survive a Borg
Invasion. We will be looking out their technology, ships, and military might.
We will also review the reason why the Borg only attack in small forces.
http://youtu.be/bflXguUO-pI
Right off the bad, he makes bad assumptions based on his feelings while
ignoring show canon. For example, he assumes the Jem'Hadar would make bad
candidates for drones because of their ketrecel-white addiction while ignoring
the fact that Borg nanoprobes and other technologies could easily deal with
their addiction to it.

Nanoprobes according to canon are capable of replacing major organs with Borg
technology. Just like they are capable of resurrecting the dead like with
Nelix. This is on top of being able to manipulate the DNA of those infected
with them along with adapt to their physiology even if it isn't initially
compatible. Just look at Doctor Phlox for that one.

If they are capable of doing those things, they can easily deal with an
addiction to the white.
Rebeca M. G.
2025-03-13 12:43:31 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Ubiquitous
In this video, We will be finding out could the Dominion survive a Borg
Invasion. We will be looking out their technology, ships, and military might.
We will also review the reason why the Borg only attack in small forces.
http://youtu.be/bflXguUO-pI
Both Federation and the Dominion are powerful but I think the Federation has the
advantage when it comes to the Borg compared to the Dominion, mainly with being
more adaptable and thinking outside the box, and even thought the Dominion are
adaptable, it's a very top-down structure that's controlled like a dictatorship,
our own history has shown that dictatorships are less adaptable compared to more
open systems.

Those bug ships of the Dominion would be like cannon fodder for the Borg and
that's before the Borg adapt to them, we've seen how powerful a Borg cube is
against much more powerful ships that a bug ships would need a heck of a lot of
numbers to do any real damage or kamikaze runs, but even then, the damage done
might not be enough against the Borg once they adapt.

As for the shapeshifters, they work quite well against other races but I'm not
sure how effective they would be with the Borg, I suspect not as effective as they
are against other races where they create paranoia and get races fighting off each
other, that wouldn't work with the Borg.

Seriously, if the Borg sent just 10 Borg cubes, that would likely do crazy amount
of damage to a fleet of Dominion ships, and even if the Dominion were to win, the
Borg can come back with far more firepower that it would take the Dominion time to
regroup, even with the impressive ability of the Dominion to do that.

I think in the end, the Dominion is about overwhelming force, I don't think that
will be very effective against the Borg once they adapt and to take the Borg on,
you have to think outside the box, become more creative and adaptive and even
thought the Dominion have shown they can do that, it's a very top down dictator
like structure with very few races that run the organisation, that likely makes it
much easier for the Borg to adapt to compared to the Federation that's countless
races with different ideas.

Regardless, if the Borg were to come in overwhelming force and not just sending 1
Borg cube, I doubt the Federation or the Dominion could beat that, but given
enough time to adapt, I think the Federation would stand a better chance, but in
truth, we've never really seen the Borg going on the offence with more than a few
ships and most of the time it's just 1 ship, so imagine 100 Borg cubes, all
adapting on the battlefield with a single mind, I can't imagine the Dominion
beating that or the Federation for that matter.
Matt Nemmers
2025-03-24 19:30:36 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Ubiquitous
In this video, We will be finding out could the Dominion survive a Borg
Invasion. We will be looking out their technology, ships, and military
might. We will also review the reason why the Borg only attack in small
forces.
http://youtu.be/bflXguUO-pI
A Founder cannot morph into a Borg without the Borg knowing the differences.
Ever Borg is connected to the Collective and if one Founder mimicking as a
Borg tried to pass off, the Borg would notice the absence of the Collective
on that drone. So, Founders cannot use subtrefuge on the Borg. The main
advantage of the Founders have is that their cellular structure may be
incompatible to assimilation through nanoprobes. If even one Vorta was
assimilated, then the Borg would know how to make Ketracel White and
assimilate all Gem'Hadar effortlessly. In the end, the Dominion would be
reduced to only founders, with the majority of its military and technology
assimilated.
BTR1701
2025-03-25 00:50:03 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Matt Nemmers
Post by Ubiquitous
In this video, We will be finding out could the Dominion survive a Borg
Invasion. We will be looking out their technology, ships, and military
might. We will also review the reason why the Borg only attack in small
forces.
http://youtu.be/bflXguUO-pI
A Founder cannot morph into a Borg without the Borg knowing the differences.
Ever Borg is connected to the Collective and if one Founder mimicking as a
Borg tried to pass off, the Borg would notice the absence of the Collective
on that drone. So, Founders cannot use subtrefuge on the Borg. The main
advantage of the Founders have is that their cellular structure may be
incompatible to assimilation through nanoprobes. If even one Vorta was
assimilated, then the Borg would know how to make Ketracel White and
assimilate all Gem'Hadar effortlessly. In the end, the Dominion would be
reduced to only founders, with the majority of its military and technology
assimilated.
They wouldn't even need to know how to produce the White. The assimilation
process would counteract and 'heal' the addiction the soldiers had to the drug
and render it irrelevant.

Loading...